Cropsey Bagels Menu

Cropsey Bagels in Brooklyn serves up a vibrant menu that captures the heart of classic New York bagel culture. Their hand-rolled, freshly baked bagels stand out—try the Whole Wheat Everything Bagel or the colorful Rainbow Bagel Sandwich for a visual and flavorful treat. The shop’s signature spreads, including fresh cream cheese and standout options like egg salad, tuna salad, and white fish salad, showcase skilled preparation and quality ingredients. For sandwich lovers, the make-your-own option on a hero or wrap offers endless customization, while specialty sandwiches like The Carousel turkey and Himalaya roast beef bring bold, layered flavors. Breakfast is a highlight with hearty plates like the Hungry Man special or sweet bites such as Banana and Blueberry Pancakes, all served with warmth and South Brooklyn charm. Beyond the food, the genuine kindness of the staff and the community vibe make every visit memorable, pairing reasonable prices with rich flavors and fast, friendly service.